Credit: Technology Review
Web
Yahoo Predicts America's Political Winners
The effort combines a variety of data-driven approaches.
- Thursday, January 19, 2012
- By Christopher Mims
Data scientists at Yahoo are using prediction markets—along with polls, sentiment analysis on Twitter, and trends in search queries—to create the mother of all political prediction engines. The project involves Web-based prediction markets like Intrade, in which large numbers of people bet on the outcomes of elections.
The researchers behind this effort, David Rothschild, an economist at Yahoo Research, and Dave Pennock, a computer scientist at Yahoo Research, call their effort the Signal. They plan to produce data visualizations that best convey probability to a lay audience, and to publish work on machine learning and fundamental economic models based on the effort.
They'll get the public involved in all this political and mathematical wonkiness with fun and games. Drawing on Yahoo's success with fantasy sports leagues—for which the company is the biggest community on the planet—Rothschild and Pennock have created "Fantasy Politics," in which users can bet on the outcomes of pretty much anything.
"We're going to let people [bet on simple predictions] like 'the Democrats will win California,' " says Pennock. "But if they want to geek out, they could bet on the odds that 'the Democrats will win both Ohio and Florida,' or 'the Republicans will win Florida but lose the election.' "
Such bets will take Yahoo's political prediction markets, which will roll out in spring, to a level of complexity and predictive power not seen elsewhere, says Pennock.
The Signal will use these markets and other real-time data streams. The prediction markets run by the Signal are polled constantly, as will be the results of analysis of Yahoo search queries and Twitter.
Sentiment analysis, or the effort to automatically determine how people feel about something based on how they communicate about it, is "at an infant stage," says Rothschild, but it can provide insight that no poll can match.
- 1
- 2






DennisBuller
119 Comments
Yahoo Predictions?
Yahoo seems to pick winners like the early scientist always found themselves to be the smartest people in their IQ tests....
Lets look at this quote in the story:
"We're going to let people [bet on simple predictions] like 'the Democrats will win California,' " says Pennock. "But if they want to geek out, they could bet on the odds that 'the Democrats will win both Ohio and Florida,' or 'the Republicans will win Florida but lose the election.' "
Two positive remarks for democrats, one negative for Republicans (win, win, win but lose)
And of course the final comment in the article is "Obama wins".
I just did an in depth mathematical computation and came to the statistic that the people at Yahoo and the writer of the article have a 92.3% chance of being Democrats.....
I also have calculated to 100% that this article should not be on a hard science website.
Reply
Chrooth
2 Comments
Re: Yahoo Predictions?
No need to be so defensive. The article is about Yahoo's data compilation engine that they plan to use as a data mining experiment to see if the information gathered is scientifically applicable to politics. Your feeling misrepresented by a hypothetical doesn't invalidate the scientific application of political data mining and analysis. Science is about remaining objective, so if you're going to preach "hard science", I would hope that you can abide by it, and try to avoid letting your obviously republican sentiments get in the way deriving what relevant value you can from what is a decently informative article.
Reply
DennisBuller
119 Comments
Re: Yahoo Predictions?
Maybe I am being a bit pricklish:)
However since they are at the beginning of this process (they freely admit it in the article) and have no proven track record of being able to predict voting with any accuracy, I think this is a nice fluff piece that belongs in Newsweek, not Technology Review.
Granted it is a technology company using technology in a new way.
But from a scientific perspective these guys are still in the lab without any positive results.
Reply
DennisBuller
119 Comments
Re: Yahoo Predictions?
"The race is pretty much over," says Rothschild. "At this point, Romney has over a 90 percent likelihood of winning the nomination, and of winning the South Carolina primary."
Gingrich won South Carolina.
While I applaud their efforts to more accurately predict peoples thoughts and voting trends, I cannot help but feel articles like this are actually an effort to fulfill their own views.
If the article was just about Yahoo's data compilation engine, why make predictions at all this early in the game?
Three days before the South Carolina Referendum?
Reply